最後更新日期 2024.01.30
Evaluation of Academic Units
最後更新日期 2024.01.30
  1. Relevant Regulations: NTU Regulations for Evaluation of Teaching and Research Units
  2. Unit in charge: Office of Academic Affairs
  3. Contact Person: Mr. Chen, Hong-Sheng
  4. Contact number: +886-2-3366-2388 #105
  5. Time: In accordance with the annual evaluation timetable of the University
  6. Notes:
    • This evaluation procedure is applicable to all teaching and research units.
    • In principle, all teaching and research units in NTU shall be evaluated once every five years.
  7. Relevant Forms to be filled and relevant documents to be consulted, etc.:
    • Previous Evaluation Records
    • Inquiry Form for Units to be Evaluated (WORD, ODF)
    • Evaluation Schedule for the 2019-2020 Academic Year (PDF)
    • Payment Criteria for Evaluation in Academic Year 2019-2020 (PDF, Chinese Version only)
    • List of Recommended Evaluators (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
    • Conflict of Interest Agreement for Evaluators (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
    • List of Evaluators to Be Appointed (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
    • Self-Evaluation Report (Blank)
      1. for departments, graduate institutes and degree programs (WORD, ODF)
      2. for research centers (WORD, ODF)
    • Sample of Site Visit Schedule (WORD, ODF)
    • Evaluator Manual
    • Evaluation Committee Member Job Description (WORD, ODF)
    • Written Review Comments on the Self-Evaluation Report & Replies from the Unit under Evaluation (WORD, ODF)
    • Final Evaluation Report (Blank)
      1. for departments, graduate institutes and degree programs (WORD, ODF)
      2. for colleges and research centers (WORD, ODF)
    • Review Comments & Improvement Plans (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
    • Final Report on Improvement Measures Taken (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
    • Appeal Form for Teaching & Research Units Evaluation (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
    • Responses to Questions Raised during On-Site Evaluation that Require Clarification (Blank) (WORD, ODF)
  8. Relevant Materials about the workshops conducted for units under evaluation:
    (Part of materials provided here contain Chinese. For further information, please contact with contact person or original authors.)
    • Academic year 2018-2019

      1. Data processing and Self-Evaluation Report preparing (PDF)

      2. Introduction to Self-accreditation Recognition (Slides not available)

    • Academic year 2017-2018

      1. Slides provided by Dr. Angela Yung-Chi Hou, Executive Director, Higher Education Evaluation & Accreditation Council of Taiwan (PDF)
      2. Slides provided by Dr. Jiunn Fang, Director, Center for Teaching Quality Assurance, Feng Chia University (PDF)
      3. Slides provided by Dr. Chau-Ron Wu, Professor of Institute of Marine Environmental Science and Technology, and former Vice President of Office of Research and Development, National Taiwan Normal University (PDF)
    • Academic year 2016-2017

      1. Dr. Bao-Jinn Wang, Professor, Graduate Institute of Education, Chung Yuan Christian University (Slides not available)
      2. M.D., Sc.D. Wei J. Chen, Dean of College of Public Health, National Taiwan University (Slides not available)
      3. Dr. Di-ching Pai, Director, Office of Quality Assurance and Audit, Tamkang University (Slides not available)
    • Academic year 2015-2016

      1. Workshop for NTU’s teaching and research units evaluation (PDF)
      2. Slides provided by Dr. Shaw-Ren Lin, Taipei National University of the Arts (PDF)
      3. Slides provided by Dr. Cheng-Chieh Yu, National Taipei University of Technology (PDF)
    • Academic year 2014-2015

      1. Workshop for NTU’s teaching and research units evaluation (PDF)
      2. Slides provided by Dr. Shu-Hui Tseng, National Taipei University of Technology (PDF
      3. Slides provided by Dr. Chun-Chi Chih, Higher Education Evaluation & Accreditation Council of Taiwan (PDF)
    • Academic year 2013-2014

      1. Workshop for NTU’s teaching and research units evaluation (PDF)
      2. Evaluation experience shared by College of Public Health (PDF)
      3. Evaluation experience shared by Department of Psychology (PDF)
      4. Evaluation experience shared by Department of Clinical Laboratory Sciences and Medical Biotechnology (PDF)
    • Academic year 2012-2013

      1. Workshop for NTU’s teaching and research units evaluation (PDF)
      2. Slides provided by Miss Xiangping Ma, former deputy director general of Department of Higher Education, MOE (PDF)
  9. Workflow

  10. Evaluation Results: